Files
Trevin Chow 52411d6e0e fix(resolve-pr-feedback): adjudicate judgment calls before escalating
A contested review item whose decision needed only judgment, not
authority the run lacks, parked as needs-human with no attempt to
decide it, which is how ce-babysit-pr ended in a stalemate. The rubric
now splits those items: authority-bound ones (security, billing, data,
product calls, out-of-envelope actions) still escalate untouched;
judgment-bound ones go to ce-pov with an oracle panel request, and a
positioned verdict inside the envelope is applied as the ordinary
verdict it names with the reasoning and concurring peers on the thread.
Blocked, no-lean, out-of-envelope, or ce-pov-unavailable results still
park, now carrying the adjudication.

Pipeline, full, and targeted modes route through the same section. A
contract test pins the split, and two eval cells plus a fixture grade
the declared route pre and post on Claude and Codex.
2026-09-22 14:25:16 -07:00
..