Files
swift-mirror/lib/AST/RequirementMachine
Slava Pestov 6d89b42462 RequirementMachine: Simplify concrete substitutions when adding a new rule
Suppose we have these rules:

  (1) [P].[P] => [P]
  (2) [P].[P:X] => [P:X]
  (3) [P].[P:Y] => [P:Y]
  (4) [P:X].[concrete: G<τ_0_0> with <[P:Y]>]

Rule (2) and (4) overlap on the following term, which has had the concrete
type adjustment applied:

  [P].[P:X].[concrete: G<τ_0_0> with <[P].[P:Y]>]

The critical pair is obtained by applying rule (2) to both sides of the
branching is

  [P:X].[concrete: G<τ_0_0> with <[P].[P:Y]>] => [P:X]

Note that this is a distinct rule from (4), and again this new rule overlaps
with (2), producing another rule

  [P:X].[concrete: G<τ_0_0> with <[P].[P].[P:Y]>] => [P:X]

This process doesn't terminate. The root cause of this problem is the
existence of rule (1), which appears when there are multiple non-trivial
conformance paths witnessing the conformance Self : P. This occurs when a
same-type requirement is defined between Self and some other type conforming
to P.

To make this work, we need to simplify concrete substitutions when adding a
new rule in completion. Now that rewrite paths can represent this form of
simplification, this is easy to add.
2021-10-27 00:29:08 -04:00
..