Commit Graph

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Slava Pestov
9ec80df97e SIL: Remove curried SILDeclRefs 2020-03-19 02:20:21 -04:00
John McCall
8be4ec32e6 Protocol requirement overrides must match in mutating-ness.
Without this change, SILGen will crash when compiling a use of the
derived protocol's requirement: it will instead attempt to use
the base protocol's requirement, but the code will have been
type-checked incorrectly for that.

This has a potential for source-compatibility impact if anyone's
using explicit override checking for their protocol requirements:
reasonable idioms like overriding a mutating requirement with a
non-mutating one will no longer count as an override.  However,
this is arguably a bug-fix, because the current designed intent
of protocol override checking is to not allow any differences in
type, even "covariant" changes like making a mutating requirement
non-mutating.  Moreover, we believe explicit override checking in
protocols is quite uncommon, so the overall compatibility impact
will be low.

This also has a potential for ABI impact whenever something that
was once an override becomes a non-override and thus requires a
new entry.  It might require a contrived test case to demonstrate
that while using the derived entry, but it's quite possible to
imagine a situation where the derived entry is not used directly
but nonetheless has ABI impact.

Furthermore, as part of developing this patch (earlier versions of
which used stricter rules in places), I discovered a number of
places where the standard library was unintentionally introducing
a new requirement in a derived protocol when it intended only to
guide associated type deduction.  Fixing that (as I have in this
patch) *definitely* has ABI impact.
2019-01-30 01:33:09 -05:00