Commit Graph

4 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
John Hui
76a1742aca [cxx-interop] Use formal C++ interop mode to fix name lookup in module interfaces (#79984)
It is possible for a module interface (e.g., ModuleA) to be generated
with C++ interop disabled, and then rebuilt with C++ interop enabled
(e.g., because ModuleB, which imports ModuleA, has C++ interop enabled).

This circumstance can lead to various issues when name lookup behaves
differently depending on whether C++ interop is enabled, e.g., when
a module name is shadowed by a namespace of the same name---this only
happens in C++ because namespaces do not exist in C. Unfortunately,
naming namespaces the same as a module is a common C++ convention,
leading to many textual interfaces whose fully-qualified identifiers
(e.g., c_module.c_member) cannot be correctly resolved when C++ interop
is enabled (because c_module is shadowed by a namespace of the same
name).

This patch does two things. First, it introduces a new frontend flag,
-formal-cxx-interoperability-mode, which records the C++ interop mode
a module interface was originally compiled with. Doing so allows
subsequent consumers of that interface to interpret it according to the
formal C++ interop mode. Note that the actual "versioning" used by this
flag is very crude: "off" means disabled, and "swift-6" means enabled.
This is done to be compatible with C++ interop compat versioning scheme,
which seems to produce some invalid (but unused) version numbers. The
versioning scheme for both the formal and actual C++ interop modes
should be clarified and fixed in a subsequent patch.

The second thing this patch does is fix the module/namespace collision
issue in module interface files. It uses the formal C++ interop mode to
determine whether it should resolve C++-only decls during name lookup.
For now, the fix is very minimal and conservative: it only filters out
C++ namespaces during unqualified name lookup in an interface that was
originally generated without C++ interop. Doing so should fix the issue
while minimizing the chance for collateral breakge. More cases other
than C++ namespaces should be added in subsequent patches, with
sufficient testing and careful consideration.

rdar://144566922
2025-03-13 23:24:18 -07:00
Egor Zhdan
7ae2bebfe8 [cxx-interop] Do not emit C++ interop flag in textual interfaces
This makes sure that the compiler does not emit `-enable-experimental-cxx-interop`/`-cxx-interoperability-mode` flags in `.swiftinterface` files. Those flags were breaking explicit module builds. The module can still be rebuilt from its textual interface if C++ interop was enabled in the current compilation.

rdar://140203932
2024-12-05 19:25:09 +00:00
Alex Lorenz
045fcf3ff5 [interop] Prohibit use of C++ APIs in public interfaces that opt-in into library evolution
The CxxStdlib overlay now has to be built without library evolution enabled.
2023-04-13 10:48:09 -07:00
Egor Zhdan
0c35771b72 [cxx-interop] Emit -enable-experimental-cxx-interop flag into the module interface
This makes sure that when Swift is generating a `.swiftinterface` file for a Swift module with a dependency on C++ module, `-enable-experimental-cxx-interop` is emitted under `// swift-module-flags:`.

The module interface might refer to C++ symbols which are not available in Swift without C++ interop enabled. This caused a build error for Swift LLVM bindings during `verify-module-interface` stage: Swift tried to import the module interface and couldn't find C++ stdlib headers because C++ interop was disabled.
2022-08-26 13:47:29 +01:00