Make sure the memory synchronization ordering on success is strictly stronger than the memory ordering of failure. This addresses a race reported by TSan when having both Swift tests and the runtime TSanified.
and MetadataCache and fix a re-entrancy bug in metadata
instantiation.
The re-entrancy bug is that we were holding the instantiation
lock of a metadata cache while instantiating metadata. Doing
so prevents us from creating a different instantiation if
it's needed by the outer instantiation. This is already
possible, but it's much more likely in a patch I'm working on
to only store the minimal metadata for generic parameters
in generic types.
The same bug could also show up as a deadlock between threads,
so a recursive lock would not be a good fix. Instead, we add
a condition variable to the metadata cache. When fetching
metadata, we look for a node in the concurrent map, eagerly
creating an empty one if none currently exists. If lookup
finds an empty node, we wait on the condition variable for
the node to become populated. If lookup succeeds in creating
an empty node, we instantiate the metadata, grab the lock,
populate the node, and notify the condition variable.
Safely creating an empty node without any metadata present
requires us to move the key data into the map entry. That,
plus a few other invariant shifts, makes it sensible to
give the user of ConcurrentMap more control over the
allocation of map nodes and the layout of keys. That, in
turn, allows us to change the contract so that keys can be
more complex than just a hash code. Instead of incrementing
hash codes and re-performing the lookup, we just insist
that lookup keys be totally ordered.
For now, I've kept the uniform use of hash codes as a
component of the key for MetadataCaches. However, hash
codes aren't really profitable for small keys, and we should
probably use direct comparisons instead.
We should also switch the safer metadata caches (i.e. the
ones that don't involve calling an arbitrary instantiation
function, like MetatypeMetadataCache) over to directly use
ConcurrentMap.
LLDB's requirement that we maintain a linked list of metadata
cache instantiations with a known layout means we can't yet
remove the CacheEntry's redundant copy of the generic
arguments.
This change cuts the number of mallocs() in the metadata caches in half.
The current metadata cache data structure uses a linked list for each entry in
the tree to handle collissions. This means that we need at least two memory
allocations for each entry, one for the tree node and one for the linked list
node.
This commit changes the map used by the metadata caches from an open hash map
(that embeds a linked list at each entry) into an closed map that uses a
different hash value for each entry. With this change we no longer accept
collissions and it is now the responsibility of the user to prevent collissions.
The new get/trySet API makes this responsibility explicit. The new design also
goes well with the current design where hashing is done externally and the fact
that we don't save the full key, just the hash and the value to save memory.
This change reduces the number of allocated objects per entry in half. Instead
of allocating two 32-byte objects (one for the tree node and one for the linked
list) we just allocate a single entry that contains the hash and the value.
Unfortunately, values that are made of two 64-bit pointers (like protocol
conformance entries) are now too big for the 32-byte tree entry and are rounded
up to 48 bytes. In practice this is not a big deal because malloc has 48-byte pool
entries.
